Auto repair businesses present unique challenges when calculating Seller's Discretionary Earnings. Between key employee dependencies, specialized skill requirements, and the common practice of owners operating as sole proprietors, there are several adjustments that differ from a typical small business valuation.
In this guide, we'll walk through a real-world transmission repair shop case study, showing how to handle these complexities and arrive at an accurate SDE figure.
The Case Study: Precision Transmission & Auto
Precision Transmission & Auto has been operating in the same location for 18 years. It's the only dedicated transmission repair shop in town, which has helped build a strong reputation and steady customer base.
The business has seven mechanics on staff, one of whom is the key employee—the lead technician who handles the most complex transmission work and trains other staff. The owner used to work on the tools but has transitioned to an oversight and customer relations role over the past several years.
The service mix breaks down as follows:
- Transmission repair: 50% of revenue
- Engine work: 30% of revenue
- Brakes and routine maintenance: 20% of revenue
One additional detail: a major local dealership sends all their warranty repair work to Precision, representing approximately 25% of total revenue. The rest comes from retail customers bringing personal vehicles for repair.
The business operates as a sole proprietorship. This is important—it affects how we calculate SDE.
Understanding Sole Proprietor Financials
In a corporation or LLC taxed as a corporation, the owner typically takes a salary that appears as a wage expense on the income statement. Net income is what's left after that salary.
In a sole proprietorship, it works differently. The owner doesn't take a formal salary—they simply keep the profits. Net income on the books is the owner's compensation.
For sole proprietors: Net Income = Owner's Total Compensation
This means we don't add back an owner's salary (there isn't one to add back). Net income already reflects what the owner takes home before any discretionary adjustments.
The Financials: Four Years of Revenue and Profit
Here's what the numbers look like:
| Item | Year 1 (Current) | Year 2 | Year 3 | Year 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue | $795,000 | $765,000 | $550,000 | $725,000 |
| Operating Expenses | ||||
| Parts & Materials | $238,500 | $229,500 | $165,000 | $217,500 |
| Technician Wages | $275,000 | $260,000 | $195,000 | $250,000 |
| Spouse Salary (Bookkeeper) | $35,000 | $35,000 | $35,000 | $35,000 |
| Rent | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| Utilities | $14,400 | $13,800 | $12,600 | $13,200 |
| Insurance | $24,000 | $22,800 | $21,600 | $20,400 |
| Vehicle Expense | $19,200 | $17,500 | $16,800 | $18,500 |
| Cell Phone | $2,500 | $2,400 | $2,300 | $2,400 |
| Meals & Entertainment | $1,400 | $1,100 | $900 | $1,400 |
| Other Operating Expenses | $40,000 | $47,900 | $65,800 | $46,600 |
| Net Income | $145,000 | $135,000 | $35,000 | $120,000 |
Notice Year 3. Revenue dropped from $725,000 to $550,000, and net income fell from $120,000 to $35,000. What happened?
Handling Anomaly Years
In Year 3, the key employee—the lead technician integral to daily operations—went on extended medical leave. Without him, the shop couldn't handle the same volume of complex work, and had to turn away jobs they would normally take. Rather than rushing to hire a replacement, the owner chose to wait for the employee to return.
The result: the shop operated at reduced capacity for most of the year. Revenue dropped 24%, and profit dropped 71%.
Important: Year 3 is an anomaly that doesn't reflect the business's normal earning capacity. Including it in a straight average would significantly understate what a buyer can expect.
We'll address this in the valuation phase (Part 2), but for now, we calculate SDE for each year separately—including Year 3—and note the anomaly clearly.
The Add-Backs: What Gets Added and Why
1. Spouse Salary: $25,500 (Partial)
The owner's spouse handles bookkeeping and is paid $35,000 annually. But what would it actually cost to hire this work done at market rates?
For a business this size with relatively straightforward books, part-time bookkeeping services run approximately $9,500 per year. The remaining $25,500 is effectively additional compensation flowing to the owner's household.
Add-back: $25,500 (the amount above market rate)
Note: We don't add back the full $35,000 because a new owner will still need bookkeeping. Only the excess above fair market value qualifies as discretionary.
2. Vehicle Expense: $18,000 (Average)
The owner runs a personal vehicle through the business. This is a common practice, but unless a buyer plans to do the same, this expense won't continue after the sale.
Add-back: ~$18,000/year (varies by year: $19,200, $17,500, $16,800, $18,500)
3. Cell Phone: $2,400 (Average)
Personal cell phone expense run through the business. Same logic as the vehicle.
Add-back: ~$2,400/year
4. Meals & Entertainment: $1,200 (Average)
Personal meals and entertainment expenses. These are discretionary and won't transfer to a new owner.
Add-back: ~$1,200/year
5. One-Time Bad Debt (Year 2 Only): $750
In Year 2, the business wrote off $750 in uncollectible receivables from a customer who went bankrupt. This was a one-time occurrence, not a recurring expense.
Add-back: $750 (Year 2 only)
The Reduction: Below-Market Rent
Here's where many business owners get tripped up—and where buyers need to pay close attention.
The owner also owns the real estate where the shop operates. Currently, the business pays $0 in rent. The owner essentially receives his property income through the business's higher net profit rather than as separate rental income.
But here's the problem: a buyer purchasing only the business (not the real estate) will need to pay rent. If fair market rent for the space is $31,000 per year, that's $31,000 that won't be available as profit.
When rent is below market rate, reduce SDE by the difference between actual rent and fair market rent.
In this case: $31,000 fair market rent − $0 actual rent = $31,000 reduction
This adjustment ensures the SDE reflects what a buyer can actually expect to earn—not what the current owner earns thanks to owning the building.
Note: If the real estate is included in the sale, this reduction wouldn't apply. But the purchase price would need to account for the property value separately. Most buyers analyze the business and real estate as distinct components.
Calculating the Normalized SDE
Now we put it together for Year 1 (most recent):
| Net Income | $145,000 |
| Add-Backs | |
| + Spouse Salary (above market) | $25,500 |
| + Vehicle Expense | $19,200 |
| + Cell Phone | $2,500 |
| + Meals & Entertainment | $1,400 |
| Reductions | |
| − Fair Market Rent Adjustment | $31,000 |
| Seller's Discretionary Earnings | $162,600 |
Here's the SDE across all four years:
| Year | Net Income | Add-Backs | Reductions | SDE |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 (Current) | $145,000 | $48,600 | $31,000 | $162,600 |
| Year 2 | $135,000 | $47,250 | $31,000 | $151,250 |
| Year 3 (Anomaly)* | $35,000 | $45,400 | $31,000 | $49,400 |
| Year 4 | $120,000 | $47,800 | $31,000 | $136,800 |
What These Numbers Tell Us
Several important observations emerge from this analysis:
The anomaly year stands out clearly. Year 3's SDE of $49,400 is less than a third of the adjacent years. Anyone analyzing this business needs to understand why—and a buyer would rightfully reduce the weight of this year when projecting future earnings.
Excluding the anomaly, the business shows healthy consistency. Years 1, 2, and 4 show SDE between $136,800 and $162,600. That's a stable earnings profile with modest growth.
The rent adjustment is significant. Without the $31,000 reduction for below-market rent, SDE would appear $31,000 higher than what a buyer will actually experience. This is exactly the kind of hidden cost that kills deals when discovered during due diligence.
The key employee dependency is a risk factor. Year 3 proves what happens when a critical team member is unavailable—the shop couldn't maintain volume or take on new work. This won't show up in the SDE calculation, but it will affect the valuation multiple a buyer is willing to pay.
What Comes Next
Calculating SDE is step one. In Part 2, we'll apply industry multiples to arrive at a valuation range—and address how to handle the anomaly year in weighted average calculations.
We'll also examine how factors like the key employee dependency and dealership revenue concentration affect what multiple a buyer should pay.
Continue to Part 2: How to Value a Transmission Repair Shop: From SDE to Sale Price
Want to Calculate Your Shop's SDE?
Our valuation tool walks you through this entire process in under 10 minutes. Enter your financials, expense adjustments, and property details—we'll calculate your weighted SDE, apply industry-specific multiples, and generate your estimated value range.
Get Your Estimate